Making Appointment the Means of Presidential Removal of Officers of the United States

Authors

David M. Driesen, Syracuse University

First Page

315

Abstract

This Article examines the relationship between appointment and removal of officers of the United States, focusing on the administrations of Andrew Jackson, Andrew Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Donald Trump. These administrations’ use of appointment and removal underlines the potential tension between political removal accomplished without Senate approval of a successor and the Constitution’s goal of securing the rule of law.

To remedy these issues, this Article proposes that Congress pass a statute forbidding presidential removal of an agency head (and other Senate-approved appointees) until the President nominates a qualified successor or until the Senate confirms a successor. Integrating Appointments Clause compliance into the removal mechanism would formalize the constitutional custom at the Founding, and further the constitutional project of keeping the Republic intact.

Recommended Citation

David M. Driesen, Making Appointment the Means of Presidential Removal of Officers of the United States, 26 Lewis & Clark L. Rev. 315 (2022).
Available at: https://lawcommons.lclark.edu/lclr/vol26/iss2/3